Each week, we offer four different kinds of homemade cookies. The flavors change from week to week, but we always have Kris’s Famous Chocolate Chip Cookies in stock! Here are the cookie flavors we offer.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Monster Cookies
Sugar Cookies
Lemon Sugar Cookies
Surprise Package
Snickerdoodles
Chocolate Crinkles
S’mores
Raspberry Almond Shortbread
White Chocolate Cranberry
Peanut Butter Temptation
Mexican Wedding Cake
Molasses
Caramel Chocolate Chip
Pricing For Our Cookies
Our cookies range from $14/dozen to $16/dozen. Most of our cookie types are $14/dozen, while any cookies that have icing (like our Sugar Cookies and Lemon Sugar Cookies) are $16/dozen. Our cookie variety boxes (usually 3 cookies of 4 different types) are also $16/dozen.
Sugar Cookies
Our delicious Vanilla Butter Sugar Cookies with Vanilla Icing are a customer favorite. Unlike most sugar cookies, these do not use royal icing. Instead, we use our special recipe for a delicious Vanilla Icing that pairs AMAZING with our Sugar Cookies, making our Sugar Cookies melt in your mouth.
Our Sugar Cookies are a popular item for custom orders. We can customize shapes and colors to make adorable Sugar Cookies for your events. Some popular events that we make Sugar Cookies for include holidays, birthday parties, showers, graduations, and more!
*Please note: since we do not use royal icing, we do not take super detailed Sugar Cookies orders. However, because of this, our Sugar Cookies can be made to order at a much lower price point than most bakeries specializing in Sugar Cookies.
Christmas Cookies
When December comes around, we offer Christmas cookies! Our Christmas cookie menu includes 12 of the cookies listed above:
- Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Sugar Cookies
- Molasses Cookies
- Monster Cookies
- Peanut Butter Blossoms
- Peanut Butter Temptations
- Surprise Package Cookies
- Snickerdoodles
- Mexican Wedding Cakes
- Raspberry Almond Shortbread
- Chocolate Crinkles
- White Chocolate Cranberry
We also offer 3 variety boxes for our Christmas cookies so you can try several cookies at once!
Place An Order For Cookies
Do you need cookies for your next big event? Whether you have a birthday, special party, or graduation, we can bake cookies for your event! Get in touch with us today!
Come Visit Us Today!
We are a family-owned bakery in the heart of Greencastle, PA. Mama K is passionate about serving the community with delicious treats that create memories. Stop by and visit us today!
Mama K’s Buns Cookie Reviews
My first experience with Mama K’s was magical, the snickerdoodles were the best cookies I’ve ever eaten
–Katelyn K.
Some of the best baked goods I (we, I now have my whole family addicted) have ever had! Kris is truly talented at making delicious & beautiful baked goods! We LOVE the cookies & Cinnamon buns.
–McKenzie M.
I ordered cookies from her after Christmas and she accommodated me and made me some and they were the best snowball cookies I’ve ever had! Thank you very much!!
–Jillian M.