Our pies are baked fresh with locally sourced ingredients. We use our special homemade pie crust as the base for all pies. Each week, our pie flavors vary. We use fresh, local fruit in our fruit pies, so our fruit pie flavors change depending on the season. Here are some of our popular types of pies.
Fresh Fruit Pies
Cherry Pie
A tart yet sweet pie loaded with cherries. Available with a crumb top or crust top. We typically have cherry pie in stock.
Blueberry Pie
A tasty pie packed with a sweet blueberry filling. Available with a crumb or crust top. We typically have blueberry pie in stock.
Strawberry Pie
An open top filled with a fresh strawberry gelatin-like filling. We use fresh strawberries and typically have strawberry pies in stock during summer.
Peach Pie
A delicious summer pie filled with sweet peach filling. Available with a crumb or crust top. We typically have peach pie in stock during peach season (around July).
Apple Pie
A classic apple pie made with local apples. Available with a crumb or crust top. We typically have this pie in stock in the fall.
Blackberry Pie
A tart yet sweet pie loaded with a delicious blackberry filling. Available with a crumb or crust top. This was a special item last summer, we typically do not have this pie in stock.
Other Popular Pies We Bake
Coconut Cream Pie
A delicious pie with a coconut custard-like filling. Topped with homemade whipped cream & toasted coconut flakes. We typically have coconut cream pie in stock.
Lemon Meringue Pie
A tangy pie with a lemon filling & topped with a light, fluffy meringue. We typically have this pie in stock during the summer.
Pecan Pie
A traditional pecan pie with a sweet gooey filling topped with pecans. We typically have pecan pie in stock.
Banana Cream Pie
Filled with a custard-like filling and packed with banana flavor. Topped with homemade whipped cream. We often have this pie in stock in the summer.
Pumpkin Pie
A traditional pumpkin pie but made with our special secrete ingredients. We have this pie in stock in the fall.
Pricing For Our Pies
Our pies are sold as full-size 9-inch pies or as smaller 6-inch pies. 9-inch pies are $20 each and 6-inch pies are $8 each.
How To Order Our Pies
Are you ready to try one of our famous pies? Contact us to place an order! We love making pies for a variety of events including birthdays, weddings, and more! If you are interested in a pie flavor not listed above, feel free to reach out and we can likely accommodate you.
Try Our Fresh Pies
Come visit us today and try our fresh pies and other baked goods. You won’t be disappointed! We are located in the heart of Greencastle, Pennsylvania and can’t wait to see you soon!
What Our Customers Say About Our Pies
Your sticky buns and mini pies for my wedding were a huge hit and so delicious! Thank you for your hard work. We are so glad we found you and you were apart of our wedding! Everything was amazing!
–Calynne P.
Mama K’s is always a win! From cinnamon rolls to cookies to cupcakes to bread and pies! My dad swears she makes the best cherry pie so he gets them regularly.
–Carla C.
The best sugar cookies E V E R and another favorite is her coconut cream pie😋
–Crystal D.